The period from 1996 to 2002 marked a unique era in video game history. During these seven years, the celebrated Nintendo 64 released its entire library of games, ultimately totaling 388 titles.
While 388 games might seem insignificant compared to today’s standards – the Nintendo Switch eShop likely sees that many new releases within a week – the focus at the turn of the millennium was on game quality rather than quantity. The N64 expertly utilized its limited selection, delivering several unforgettable classics.
In honor of my personal favorite retro console, let’s revisit and rank the best games from each year the N64 received new titles.
This compilation will determine a top game from each year between 1996 and 2002 based on critical acclaim at the time, then rank them according to my personal preferences and how well they’ve aged.
Note: North American release dates will be used. MetaCritic will be the primary source for critical reception data, as OpenCritic doesn’t offer as much historical coverage.
7
2002 – Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3
MetaCritic Score: Unavailable
Tony Hawk’s Pro Skater 3 wins by default as the only N64 game launched in 2002. The console ceased production the year before, which meant no more new games. Still, Tony Hawk squeezed in one final appearance on the N64.
While I enjoy the THPS franchise, with the third installment being a personal favorite, the N64 version wasn’t the optimal choice. The PS2 edition offered significantly superior graphics and controls. Looking at N64 THPS3 screenshots can feel surreal if you experienced it primarily on PlayStation.
Ultimately, it’s a decent game that didn’t significantly improve upon the first two N64 versions as the console was nearing obsolescence in 2002. Only hardcore N64 collectors who want the system’s last game truly own it.
6
1997 – GoldenEye 007
MetaCritic Score: 96
GoldenEye 007 was a groundbreaking title. Few N64 games carry as much historical importance. It might even be why I always invert my Y-axis in games, since GoldenEye defaulted to that setting. If you were around in 1997, you understand its cultural impact.
However, the game’s aged… poorly. While GoldenEye 007 significantly influenced console FPS games, it’s difficult to revisit now outside of nostalgia or historical curiosity.
I will say that the 4-player split-screen multiplayer provided countless hours of fun with friends and my brother. The single-player campaign, based on the movie, is amusing today and has its own charm.
Other strong contenders for 1997 included Blast Corps, Diddy Kong Racing, and Star Fox 64. Although I might have personally chosen DKR or Star Fox, GoldenEye’s impact on a generation of players is undeniable.
5
2000 – Perfect Dark
MetaCritic Score: 97
Perfect Dark was developed by Rare, the same team responsible for GoldenEye 007. The studio remarkably produced two of the N64’s best shooters, both considered top games for their release years.
Perfect Dark, built upon GoldenEye’s foundation, had three extra years of refinement. While still an N64 FPS without a second joystick for aiming, it was another triumph for Rare. Back then, it felt like lightning striking twice.
Joanna Dark became an instant icon, though she didn’t receive the recognition she deserved, especially after the AAA Perfect Dark reboot’s cancellation. Nevertheless, the original Perfect Dark in 2000 had a moment, despite my mom preventing me from playing it at the time.
The Legend of Zelda: Majora’s Mask would have been my choice for 2000 without critical opinion weighing in, but Perfect Dark is certainly a worthy champion.
This is the last time I’ll disagree with the critics on this list. I agree with the choices for the remaining four years.
4
1999 – Mario Golf
MetaCritic Score: 91
While I appreciate the games mentioned so far, the remaining choices are personal favorites. Toadstool Tour on the GameCube is among the best sports games ever, made possible by the original Mario Golf on the N64 (yes, Mario played golf on the NES, but not quite like this).
Mario Golf still holds up exceptionally well and is enjoyable for anyone who can access it. A highlight is the mini-golf mode, simple but something Nintendo hasn’t revisited in subsequent titles.
The N64 version introduced quirky human characters, like Sonny with his cowboy hat. While later golf games surpassed it, Mario Golf remains fun decades later.
3
1996 – Super Mario 64
MetaCritic Score: 94
Super Mario 64 launched with the N64 in 1996, and it’s difficult to find a launch title as impactful for its system. Defining what a console-seller should be, Super Mario 64 forever changed video games, setting the standard for 3D platformers.
Back in ’96, young Ethan returned home from preschool to find his older brother playing Mario 64, and nothing was ever the same. It was the first game I obsessed over.
Each painting offered a new surprise, and core memories remain, from tossing a baby penguin off a cliff to manipulating time in Tick Tock Clock. The camera is dated, but otherwise, Super Mario 64 holds up well and is a must-play.